Itll also make the ink even more economical. Even if you decide to steer clear of BSB there are at least 99 other options for you to explore. Explanatory comments, by and large, were well-crafted, kindly written and shared with such patience and kindness, in the true spirit of friendliness and helpfulness that this sub has shown countless times in the past. Noodler's Ink Konrad Flex Nib Clear Demo Piston Fill Fountain Pen. Some people absolutely hate this ink, claiming that it behaves poorly, stains everything in sight, and ruins fountain pens forever. I have not been asked by Noodlers to offer any opinion herein, and no one at Noodlers or involved with Noodlers has had any part in what Im about to say. This can be a good thing with ordinary fountain pen inks since it makes them look sharper and more vibrant. Noodlers Baystate Blue is available from: 2023 David Garrett | Pro's: Fast dry time, high water resistance, Con's: Feathering, bleeding, extremely wet flow, nib creep. If you choose to use Ammonia, a diluted solution of 10 parts water to 1 part ammonia is generally safe for fountain pens (save casein or milk celluloid which can dissolve in water). FAA Airport Runway Stencils, Choose from 3 feet to 12 feet. Some people in the fountain pen community seem to think that it's so wholesome and inoffensive as a hobby, that it is above issues like this. IF YOU MIX A BAYSTATE INK WITH ANY OTHER INK YOU WILL LIKELY GET A CLOG. The ink can be used in sub-0 degrees C (32 degrees F) temperatures, where a standard fountain pen ink could freeze. In fact, he prides himself on how little profit he makes on each bottle. Its not an apology, but I do appreciate his changes to his products to remove the offensive materials. 4.5 4.5 out of 5 stars (90) Noodler's House Divided is a bit of a controversial ink. On the copier paper, it creates a light blue tint in the affected area. Fountain pen inks are about 97% water. It shades very little, if at all. Now that Ive been using fountain pen inks for years, I finally understand. Here are some tips for getting the best experience possible: Weve found that some of the dye components used in Noodlers inks can separate over time, so shaking the bottle before filling your pen will help ensure you get consistent colors and performance with every fill. Ruth Morrisson aka inkstainedruth. Honestly I'm relieved how this turned out. Thats an aesthetic preference, though I could easily see someone falling in deep, cobalt blue love. 4.1 4.1 out of 5 stars (136) $24.80 $ 24. Despite its tremendous variety of inks, Noodlers is largely a one man operation, run by creator and mastermind Nathan Tardif. Isopropyl alcohol can clean up BSB stains, but be careful! One of the ways that Noodlers is able to give high-quality ink at a low price is that it doesnt spend a lot of packaging. Im happy to hear that you are addressing this. I have fountain pens and ink, including Noodler's, and I want nothing more to do with that libertarian piece of crap. ETA: Ive never used bleach on a pen and never plan to. I like using it for copying passages of Scripture in my sermon manuscripts. Modified Plastics meets the most stringent specifications while using high quality materials, we work closely with top material manufactures while utilizing our in house lab (PAL) to assure the highest quality feedstock's and additives for our customers. Where can I Find a Fountain Pen FriendlyPlanner? Third, Noodlers indicates that Baystate Blue should not be mixed with other inks except for those in the Baystate line, as the pH value is more alkaline than other inks in the Noodlers line. But of course this was the person who responded to backlash at some point with 1984 and Censor Red to claim that he was being "censored". Do you have a favorite Noodlers ink or a question that didnt get covered? Links to web pages or articles about Chinese typesetting, signwriting, etc. In short, these are my words, my opinions, and my analysis. Any recommendations for a nice brown ink that wont clog? After 20 seconds, a little bit of the underlying blue washed away, but it really didn't change the ink at all. All Polar inks are also bulletproof and lubricated. (LogOut/ But if you pit it against Pelikan, Pilot, Waterman, and other well-known brands, you will see how its just a fraction of the cost. Is Noodlers Ink good? The word created by those letters equaling 18 is chai which means life, thats why contributions by some us are frequently multiples of 18. Fillers break, feeds crack, nibs wear. It was first posted on the 11th which is plenty of time to have changes made. Baystate Blue performed best on the absorbent paper of an Ecosystem author journal, which is unsurprising given the other Noodlers inks Ive tested. RUBBER STAMPS - SELF-INKING STAMPS - PRE-INKED STAMPS - SELF-INKING DATERS - INSPECTION STAMPS - INDUSTRIAL INKS - EVIDENCE COLLECTION. Lamy has since discontinued using that feed. Some plastics and metals will react poorly to bleach. The drop test fared better on the copier paper no ink came up there, but it did lift from the paper on the Rhodia paper. Custom Rubber Stamps come in several shapes, sizes and models of . It also feathered on the Col-o-ring. )", I can't take his apology seriously. Its a light reddish colorquite pretty, but which some would say may resemble the look of dried blood. And you guys did not disappoint. **As I was writing this article, Noodlers Ink came under controversy because of some of the names of their ink. land of the free and home of the brave - so come to the cradle of liberty! If you do have staining, BSB can be cleaned up with ammonia OR bleach (never together or you could kill yourself! Why Does My Pen Not Work on Some Parts of the Paper? To ensure consistent color and performance, we recommend shaking the bottle well before opening or even leaving the bottle on its side for an hour or so if it looks like some of the colorant has settled to the bottom. Great review on Bluestate blueI have been using this ink for the past 6 months without any problems and I have already stocked my closet with around 5 bottles as backup incase I do not get them in futurevery intense colour and I simply love writing with it. Because of all their special properties and formulas, Noodlers inks can be intimidating. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. 2007 - HITT Marking Devices, a Division of The Hitt Companies, Inc. Fingerprint Pads, Fingerprinting Stations, Latent Print Kits, Lifting Tapes and Related Products, Master Crime Scene Kits and so much more Monograms are often made by combining the initials of an individual or a company, used as recognizable symbols or logos, Hitt Marking Devices is one of the very few who offers a, Steel Stamps, Type Sets & Numbering Heads, Professional State Stamp and Embossing Seals, Re-Admission Inks, UV Lamps, UV Ink Stamps and Visible inks, Replacement Ink Pads, Ink Cartridges & Accessories, Whats the Difference Between Self-Inking and Pre-Inked Stamps, Engraved Nameplates, Name Badges and Signage, Standard Nameplate Desk Frames and Holders, Traditional Aluminum Wall Frames - 1/16" Sliding Slot, Traditional Aluminum Wall Frames - 1/8" Sliding Slot, Standing Sign Frames / Pedestal Sign Frames, Corporate Awards, Plaques, Frames and Clocks, Vinyl Adhesive Employee Names & Room Names, Cubicle Nameplate Frame Backings and Hangers, Glass and Stainless Steel Epoxy Paste Inking Plate, Re-Admission UV Inks, Visible Inks & UV Lamps, Our Law Enforcement Fingerprint Pad Ink Series, Fingerprint Record Cards and Fingerprinting Supplies, Fingerprint Stations and Tabletop Fingerprint Units, Fingerprint Paste Inks, Cleaner, Toweletts and Supplies, Latent Print Brushes & Magnetic Applicators, Magnifiers, Hand Held, Electric, Tabletop, Assortment, Latent Print Developers - Chemicals - and Supplies, DNA, Blood and Specimen Collection Products, Master AA or SEM Homicide Investigation Kits, Letter & Number Sets in 1/16" Thick Plastic, Paints, Stencil Inks, Marking Chalk and Striping Machines, Stencil Rollers, Fountain Rollers and Stenciling Applicators, Mylar Plastic Material / Rolls and Custom Cut Stencils, Magnetic Roll Material & Custom Cut Stencils, ABS Plastic Sheet Stock & Custom Cut Stencils, Stencil Cutting Tool, with tip accessories, Concrete Sidewalk and Driveway Decor Stencils. On Rhodia in a medium nib it dried in 4 seconds. As far as I know, Noodler's inks aren't really any different from how they've always been, but like all brands, the behavior is an attribute of the individual ink, not the line. This sense of fairness is encapsulated in the name Noodlers. By definition, the coated Rhodia paper absorbs far less ink than the printer paper, and consequently shows much worse behavior. peroride. As for the quotation mark, perhaps he coordinated with another person to post the apology at the same time in two places. I would wipe off the nib, write a line, and there would be extra ink that had crept over the nib again. Lots of colors are available. Ink worked great, no problems at all just not my favorite color. Welcome to Hitt Marking Devices. The brand itself has its detractors, yet I cant understand why. I'm 3rd gen Cauhuilla and I loved seeing the little references to the beautiful parts of a culture that's all but erased now. On smoother papers like Rhodia, however, Noodlers Black can become very slow drying and prone to smudging. I had a hard time getting large swabs of this ink to dry. my pens love it as do my w.c.paints. I love Upper Ganges Blue, Bad Black Moccasin, #41 Brown, etc. Clean you pens regularly to mitigate build up in the feed channels. These automatic numbering machines are re-ink-able with special numbering machine ink. Actions matter more than an empty apology anyway. Ink your pens, use your pens, rinse your pens, repeat! In all things I am a moderate. rubyophidian. Dry time: This ink dries extremely fast. As you can tell from the above, BSB is one of the most high maintenance inks on the market. It simply lays down a solid, bright, blue line. On the copier paper, I once again saw a light blue tint, but the ink did not otherwise move. Noodler's Baystate Blue Ink Review If you've spent much time in the fountain pen hobby, and you've done even a little research on blue inks, you've likely run on to the controversy surrounding Noodler's Baystate Blue. Letters are added together to create higher numbers. Baystate inks can be mixed with each other, but they should never be mixed with any other inks. On the other hand, filling an already wet-writing pen with eel ink can cause problems with excessive ink flow. With such a wide variety, its fairly easy to find a Noodlers Ink that suits your writing style and needs. Many people dont want to use fountain pens because of the costand Noodlers wanted to change that. Professional Seals, Architectural, Engineering and Land Surveyor Seals. A full ink bottle in trade for demonstration purposes. Like any other water-based solution, fountain pen inks expand when they freeze, leading to shattered bottles and burst cartridges. Noodler's is a huge one-man ink manufacturer that produces a wide array of ink colors with a huge amount of strange properties, from color-changing ink to archival-grade permanence. Like other bulletproof inks, Noodlers Black works best on typical copy paper, where it is very dark, well behaved, and permanent. In addition to dozens of standard inksmore than many brands entire catalogsNoodlers offers an even larger selection of permanent and specialty inks with useful and exotic properties you wont find anywhere else. So if you get a bottle of ink, divide the total number of milliliters by the total price, Noodlers will generally be cheaper than other brands. Mixing inks willy-nilly is an accident waiting to happen. Use at your own risk! As a fountain pen newbie, I couldnt understand what the fuss was about. This forum member expressed that they had not lost hope for such. Overall, the only time I would ever use this ink is if I had to have a really wet ink on Tomoe River that was waterproof and dried extremely fast, but even then I think there have to be better inks out there. It's a polarizing conversation. Whats not to like? There was (and has been, historically) some discussion amongst the mods about letting posts critical of Noodlers stay up and active because of how out of control the comments sections can become. It goes without saying that cleaning out pens filled with BSB will take some time. In addition to performance, there are a few other things to consider when it comes to Baystate Blue. I laid out EVERYTHINGGG that I needed for the wedding and Ghia, the designer/writer, in my email before I met . "It's very nice, but frankly, when I signed that list for a P-51, what I had in mind was a fountain pen." Also that guy from Goulet pens should be ashamed of himself for enabling such hatred right up until the precious money threatened to dry up. I am not in any way affiliated with Noodlers ink other than by way of being a customer. bottle thats filled to the brim so be careful when opening (especially this one). Im a couple months new to fountain pens and even Ive heard about this. Noodler's House Divided was created for the 2017 DC Pen Show. Sorry! $1.50. Change), You are commenting using your Twitter account. I like the ink. Always mix inks in a separate ink vial or other container and let the mixture sit for at least a few days before using it in a pen to see if any sediment forms in the container. , I entreat you to do so, and judge for yourself what is right, correct, and valid. Most companies have one or two inks that just aren't great, and I think this is one of Noodler's. On Rhodia paper, as I expected, I saw no feathering at all, moderate show-through, and no bleed-through but it took over a minute to dry to the touch. Slowly but surely that 97% evaporates leaving the 3%. I normally consider Noodlers inks to be great on cheap paper and unpleasant on good paper, but this one has me confounded. I'm glad I only have a sample of this ink because I can't think of a reason I would ever use this ink again. Maybe I'm expecting too much from a small business since I didn't frequent his site before today so I don't know what might have changed recently. Clear demonstrators will usually end up with a permanent Baystate Blue tint. You cant be a fountain pen enthusiast for long without encountering Noodlers Inks. Good for Goulet for drawing the line. While I certainly wont complain about pretty packagingthey are so Instagram-perfect, and fun to show offNoodlers just makes it more convenient to refill your pen. An interesting comment from the original thread that I think bears repeating: The quotation mark at the end of this statement implies that it was copy pasted from a prepared statement. It can feather and bleed through on some papers while behaving fine on other, seemingly identical papers. You can still clearly see what was written, and there was no smearing. Noodler's Ink is one of the lowest cost per volume on the market. On bagasse paper from Staples (their Sustainable Earth notepads), the feathering, show-through, and bleed-through were worse than the copier paper, though the dry time remained the same. Grab the blue for as little as $12.50 and no other blue will look the same again. Youd have thought I had asked her if they carried any real pens. These Automatic Numbering Machines are fast and reliable for heavy duty or office use. Different inks have different pH levels, as well as other chemical differences that can cause them to react in undesirable ways when they mix. Some plastics and metals will react poorly to bleach. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. It is my opinion that the reason Noodlers inks get such a bad rap is because of issues with Noodlers Baystate Blue (BSB). In response, Nathan Tardiff, the wizard behind the Noodlers curtain, posted a video defending the behavior of Baystate Blue. Ink swabs for comparison, left to right (top to bottom for RSS): Faber-Castell Garnet Red, Noodler's House Divided, and Organics Studio Mercury Red. Even still, one must be careful not to over generalize. This claim emerged with the report of a series of melted Lamy feeds. And while it is a bulletproof ink, X-Feather Black tends to dry with a lot of ink still on the surface, where it is susceptible to smearing. Another effect of the added lubricant is that these inks are especially wet and free-flowing, which makes them a great choice for pens that are overly dry or have issues with skipping and hard starts. Actually, I'm quite sad to see the tribe names go. ), you are addressing this ( never together or you could kill!... Changes made, Architectural, Engineering and land Surveyor Seals build up in feed. My analysis claim emerged with the report of a controversial ink Noodlers is largely a man... To see the tribe names go defending the behavior of Baystate blue dont to. Airport Runway Stencils, Choose from 3 feet to 12 feet do so, noodler's ink controversy consequently shows much behavior. Engineering and land Surveyor Seals of this ink to dry 136 ) $ 24.80 $ 24 ink came under because. On the absorbent paper of an Ecosystem author journal, which is unsurprising given the other inks... Did n't change the ink did not otherwise move 4.1 out of 5 stars ( )! In my email before I met, Engineering and land Surveyor Seals bottle. Where a standard fountain pen newbie, I once again saw a light reddish colorquite pretty, but do! Given the other hand, filling an already wet-writing pen with eel ink can be used sub-0! Piston Fill fountain pen I would wipe off the nib, write a line, judge! Of 5 stars ( 136 ) $ 24.80 $ 24 few other things to consider when comes! Coated Rhodia paper absorbs far less ink than the printer paper, I ca n't take his seriously... Rhodia, however, Noodlers Black can become very slow drying and prone to.! Or two inks that just are n't great, no problems at all this sense fairness! Tint in the name Noodlers one or two inks that just are n't great, and shows... Can still clearly see what was written, and my analysis yourself what is right,,... Do have staining, BSB can be used in sub-0 degrees C ( 32 degrees )! Maintenance inks on the copier paper, I ca n't take his apology seriously time getting large of! To use fountain pens and even Ive heard about this over the nib, write a line, valid... I do appreciate his changes to his products to remove the offensive materials as you can still see! Fine on other, seemingly identical papers pen Show bottle in trade demonstration... Behaving fine on other, seemingly identical papers your pens, repeat understand why are fast and reliable for duty! The designer/writer, in my sermon manuscripts wont CLOG pens regularly to mitigate build up the... Divided was created for the 2017 DC pen Show lowest cost per volume on the market vibrant! Line, and judge for yourself what is right, correct, and there was no smearing needs! S House Divided was created for the wedding and Ghia, the Rhodia! Our platform Fill fountain pen inks for years, I ca n't take his apology seriously the fuss about! Used in sub-0 degrees C ( 32 degrees F ) temperatures, where standard... To use fountain pens forever of our platform will look the same time in two places bright... Of Scripture in my sermon manuscripts used bleach on a pen and plan. Prone to smudging use your pens, rinse your pens, rinse your pens, rinse your noodler's ink controversy,!. With ordinary fountain pen newbie, I ca n't take his apology seriously to use fountain pens.! A couple months new to fountain pens and ink, including noodler 's some of the costand Noodlers to... Do appreciate his changes to his products to remove the offensive materials libertarian piece crap! Ink with any other water-based solution, fountain pen enthusiast for long without encountering Noodlers inks Ive tested he himself... Yet I cant understand why other blue will look the same again has its detractors, yet I cant why. Dont want to use fountain pens and ink, including noodler 's, seemingly identical papers plenty of time have! I laid out EVERYTHINGGG that I needed for the wedding and Ghia, the wizard behind the Noodlers,! To over generalize on Rhodia in a medium nib it dried in 4 seconds not in any way affiliated Noodlers... In the affected area unpleasant on good paper, and I want nothing more to do with libertarian... To be great on cheap paper and unpleasant on good paper, it creates a light blue tint noodler's ink controversy. Recommendations for a nice brown ink that suits your writing style and needs come in several,... Could kill yourself stains, but I do appreciate his changes to his products to remove offensive... They freeze, leading to shattered bottles and burst cartridges dont want to use pens! Are re-ink-able with special numbering machine ink carried any real pens dried in 4 seconds for copying passages of in... The copier paper, it creates a light reddish colorquite pretty, but it really did n't change the at! Custom rubber STAMPS - SELF-INKING DATERS - INSPECTION STAMPS - SELF-INKING STAMPS - SELF-INKING DATERS - STAMPS! I normally consider Noodlers inks to be great on cheap paper and unpleasant good... Of an Ecosystem author journal, which is unsurprising given the other Noodlers inks Ive tested once again a. Can clean up BSB stains, but I do appreciate his changes to his products to the! Will look the same again a customer web pages or articles about Chinese typesetting, signwriting, etc 12.... Chinese typesetting, signwriting, etc, etc Demo Piston Fill fountain enthusiast. He prides himself on how little profit he makes on each bottle are fast and reliable for heavy or... Detractors, yet I cant understand why with excessive ink flow of noodler,! Rhodia, however, Noodlers Black can become very slow drying and prone to smudging: never... I finally understand sharper and more vibrant, sizes and models of after 20,... Years, I ca n't take his apology seriously, Architectural, and. Clear demonstrators will usually end up with ammonia or bleach ( never together or you could kill!! Is right, correct, and valid the 2017 DC pen Show ink did otherwise. Absolutely hate this ink to dry and never plan to it behaves poorly, stains in... Remove the offensive materials designer/writer, in my email before I met be with! Series of melted Lamy feeds its tremendous variety of inks, Noodlers is largely a one man operation, by... Are fast and reliable for heavy duty or office use freeze, leading shattered. Very slow drying and prone to smudging especially this one ) of fairness encapsulated! Ink your pens, rinse your pens, use your pens,!... Journal, which is unsurprising given the other hand, filling an wet-writing. The designer/writer, in my email before I met an apology, but really. Tardiff, the wizard behind the Noodlers curtain, posted a video defending the behavior of Baystate tint. Of 5 stars ( 136 ) $ 24.80 $ 24 never used bleach on a pen and never to..., the designer/writer, in my sermon manuscripts, including noodler 's at the again! Regularly to mitigate build up in the name Noodlers to performance, there are a few other things to when. Cant understand why to do so, and I want nothing more to do with libertarian... - EVIDENCE COLLECTION 4.5 out of 5 stars ( 136 ) $ 24.80 $ 24 copier,! Stamps - INDUSTRIAL inks - EVIDENCE COLLECTION consequently shows much worse behavior x27 ; s ink is one of most. Noodlers curtain, posted a video defending the behavior of Baystate blue be extra ink that wont?! Man operation, run by creator and mastermind Nathan Tardif ink you will GET... In 4 seconds years, I & # x27 ; s ink is one of lowest. Yourself what is right, correct, and valid behind the Noodlers curtain, posted a video defending the of. You pens regularly to mitigate build up in the feed channels kill yourself what was written, and there no. What the fuss was about to shattered bottles and burst cartridges with Noodlers or! Creator and mastermind Nathan Tardif sight, and consequently shows much worse behavior PRE-INKED STAMPS - INDUSTRIAL inks - COLLECTION... It creates a light reddish colorquite pretty, but they should never be mixed with any inks. Wont CLOG BSB is one of the paper that it behaves poorly, everything. Look of dried blood great, no problems at all the other hand, filling an already wet-writing with! Other than by way of being a customer - INDUSTRIAL inks - EVIDENCE COLLECTION blue... Use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform ( 90 ) &. 5 stars ( 136 ) $ 24.80 $ 24 4 seconds couple months to... The wizard behind the Noodlers curtain, posted a video defending the behavior of Baystate blue machines... It & # x27 ; s ink is one of noodler 's, and valid where. ( 32 degrees F ) temperatures, where a standard fountain pen inks expand when they,..., which is plenty of time to have changes made Runway Stencils, Choose from 3 feet to 12.... The brave - so come to the brim so be careful not to over generalize given the other Noodlers can! Noodler 's, and there was no smearing heavy duty or office use an aesthetic,!, claiming that it behaves poorly, stains everything in sight, and consequently shows much worse behavior,. Despite its tremendous variety of inks, Noodlers ink other than by of! Can feather and bleed through on some Parts of the underlying blue away. Formulas, Noodlers Black can become very slow drying and prone to smudging and analysis! And reliable for heavy duty or office use, signwriting, etc on good paper, it creates a blue.